November12, 2001Mr. Dexter Rutherford
Superintendent
Lawrence County School System
14131 Market Street
Moulton, AL 35650
Re: Confederate Symbols in Lawrence County Schools
Dear Mr. Rutherford:
It was a pleasure meeting with you last week in your office and at the
meeting of the Lawrence County Board of Education. As we stated, it is
the
position of the Sons of Confederate Veterans to cooperate and assist the
public schools in their mission of educating the next generation of
Alabama
citizens. Part of that position demands that we support the
Constitutional
and civil rights of all Lawrence County students when we take the
position
that the respectful use of the Confederate flag on clothing is protected
by
the United States and Alabama Constitutions and the Civil Rights Act of
1964.
Because the problem seems to lie in the lack of knowledge regarding
Confederate symbols among a small minority of Lawrence County students
and
administrators, the Sons of Confederate Veterans want to provide a
comfort
level for the Lawrence County schools that will allow them to return
Confederate symbols to their rightful place in a school setting.
Pursuant to our promise to you and the Board of Education, the Alabama
Division, Sons of Confederate Veterans, the Southern Legal Resource
Center,
and Yow & Associates have thoroughly discussed this matter and in return
for
restoring respectful use of the Confederate flag to the Lawrence County
schools, we make the following proposal:
1. Lawrence County in the War Between the States
With the help of student members in the Moulton SCV Camp, the Alabama
Division will prepare and install an exhibit made up of letters,
photographs
and maps of the War in Lawrence County, underscoring the incredible
hardships and tragedies suffered by all the citizens of Lawrence County
during a very turbulent period.
2. Teaching y’all tolerance
A one-hour to one-day seminar conducted by Mr. H. K. Edgerton of the
Southern Legal Resource Center. Mr. Edgerton is chairman of the Board of
Advisors of the SLRC and is a past president of the Asheville. North Carolina, NAACP. The program is based on The Consideration of Others Program in use by the United States Army. Students will participate in groups of 10 to 20 with an adult team leader in a seminar designed to foster self-respect and respect for the beliefs and values of others and how those beliefs or values are different from or the same as other seminar members. Seminar members will discuss the Bill of Rights and how those rights are affected by the school environment. Respect for other beliefs, customs and values will be stressed as necessary to preserve a learning environment in a diverse school system. Students completing the seminar will sign a pledge to respect the beliefs of others. Part of the program might include a consideration of others skit performed before a school assembly. Several programs on the First Amendment in school are available from the Freedom
Forum of Arlington, Virginia. For those students who complete the program and sign the pledge, the school would allow them to inoffensively wear symbols such as the Confederate Flag or Malcolm X. Violation of the terms of the pledge cancels the student’s right to wear their symbol. This program was implemented by an assistant principal at Woodford High School in Woodford, Kentucky. The program was successful until her retirement and the program was discontinued.
3. Essay Contest
Offered by the Alabama Division, Sons of Confederate Veterans -- $100.00
on
Lawrence County in the War Between the States. Three prizes available:
one
each of $100.00 for high school, middle school and primary school.
4. Essay Contest
Offered by the Southern Legal Resource Center -- $100.00 on Free Speech
and
Responsibility in a School Setting. Two prizes available: one each of
$100.00 for high school and middle school.
5. Essay Contest
Offered by Charles Yow, Sr., Yow & Associates Law Firm -- $100.00 on
Native
Americans Who Serve the Confederacy. Three prizes available: one each of
$100.00 for high school, middle school and primary school.
6. Library Books
Books on Southern and Confederate History, Civil and Constitutional
Rights,
and Native American topics will be donated for use in the Lawrence
County
School System.
7.
Reenactment encampment
To be organized by local reenactors under the supervision of the Alabama
Division, Sons of Confederate Veterans. War Between the States military
encampment utilizing Union and Confederate soldiers, with Infantry,
Artillery and Cavalry arms represented. 1860’s civilians may also
participate. Where possible, reenactment soldiers will demonstrate camp
life, drill, and use of black powder weapons, as well as first person
interpretation on soldier life in the 1860’s. Students will learn 19th
Century drill (good for JROTC).
8. Field trip
The sky is the limit; will have a War Between the States
theme.
9. Music program
Will introduce students to Alabama music of the
1840’s,
50’s, and 60’s as performed on original instruments. This could include
fifes and drums and a Confederate Military Brass Band concert. Coordinated
with the musical program will be a seminar on 19th Century dance, social
graces, and deportment. The final exam will be a 19th Century Ball at
the
end of the school year.
10. History and Controversy of the Confederate
Battle Flag
Seminar discussing the history of the Confederate flag, its true
symbolism
and its place in modern life. This can include a discussion of the
religious aspects of Confederate symbolism where appropriate.
11. Women’s seminar
Will present the woman’s world of mid-19th Century Alabama to include a
fashion show of the 19th Century fashion to be presented by student
models.
12. Genealogy
Presented by the Alabama Division Sons of Confederate Veterans. Seminar
participants will learn the rudiments of genealogy research and will
learn
by researching their own family.
13. Church Service
A 19th Century Church Service will be offered
off-campus for interested students.
14. The Confederate experience in Alabama
Seminar sponsored by the Alabama Division, SCV, will cover all aspects
of
the Alabama experience between 1860 and 1865. Seminar will include
civilian, military, men, women, free and slave experience. Mr. H. K.
Edgerton and Mr. Nelson Winbush of Florida will be available to discuss
the
African-American experience in the War, especially those blacks, free
and
slave, who loyally served the Confederacy.
The attached Guide to Confederate Issues in North Carolina will be used
as
text for this seminar. The Guide is now being prepared with an Alabama
perspective.
As you can see from the many programs that can be offered to students of
Lawrence County, coordination with school officials and community
members
will be essential. Obviously all the programs cannot be offered at the
same
time.
After your Board has had a chance to digest this information, please
call
at your earliest opportunity so we can choose the appropriate next step.
The Alabama Division, the Southern Legal Resource Center, and Yow &
Associates look forward to working with the Lawrence County School
System to
implement this exciting program for Lawrence County students.
Sincerely,
Steve Turner
Northwest Brigade Commander
Sons of Confederate Veterans
CC: Avery Hudson
Kirk D. Lyons, Esq.
Charles Yow, Sr., Esq.
Thomas McAlpine, Esq.
Larry Becraft, Esq.
The SLRC is non-profit,
tax exempt, South Carolina
public law firm that specializes in cases involving Southern Heritage
violations.
PLEDGE TODAY!
Please visit the Southern Legal Resource Center's web site at
http://www.slrc-csa.org
We encourage those who support us to sign a monthly pledge so that our
work may continue. You can also now contribute online through paypal by
following this link
https://www.paypal.com/xclick/business=slrc%40slrc-csa.org.
If anyone has received this who does not
wish to be on our distribution list, please let us know. Our address is
SLRC, P.O. Box 1235, Black Mountain, NC 28711. Phone: 828-669-5189 Dr.
Payne and Atty. Lyons SCV members, I.N. Giffen,758, Black Mountain, NC