September 6, 2002
By TOM STEADMAN, Staff Writer
News & Record
GREENSBORO -- Guilford County Schools
officials apologized to local leaders of the United Daughters of the
Confederacy Thursday afternoon, saying they made a "poor decision" last
week when a middle school principal halted the UDC's annual essay and
art contest and compared the group to the Ku Klux Klan.
"We want to sincerely apologize for anything we
said or did that was offensive to the UDC," Aycock Principal Melissa
Harrelson and teacher Jean Botzis wrote in a letter given to officers of
the Guilford UDC chapter at an hour-long meeting at the school.
"We made a poor decision based on incorrect
information," the letter said. "We were trying to respond to a parent's
request to remove their child from any further recognition or
participation in the essay contest. It could have been handled better
and we are sorry that it wasn't."
UDC leaders said the essay and art contest,
offered to local school students for more than 50 years on a voluntary
basis, will resume at Aycock later this year.
Contest topics, suggested by the UDC chapter's
historian, vary each year. This year's suggested topics for high school
entrants included "The War Between the States in the North Carolina
Mountains."
Ten local schools participated in this year's
contest, held last spring. A total of 67 students won awards, and the
UDC gave $395 in prizes, Bissell said.
Harrelson, Botzis and central office administrator
Barry Williams represented the school system at the meeting, said Ellen
Bissell, program chairman of the Guilford UDC chapter. "They were very,
very apologetic," Bissell said.
"They sincerely were distressed that all this had
happened. I think we'll have a good relationship in the future."
The flap broke out last week, when Botzis sent a
letter to the UDC, a heritage group of female descendants of Confederate
veterans, requesting that the name of an eighth-grade essay contest
winner or any other entrants at Aycock not be entered in further
competition or published in affiliation with the UDC.
That letter said the "philosophy and goals" of the
UDC conflicted with those of Aycock Middle School. Then, in a telephone
conversation that day with the News & Record, Harrelson, the Aycock
principal, described the UDC as a "modern-day version of the Ku Klux
Klan."
Harrelson refused to discuss Thursday's meeting
with the News & Record. But Aycock PTA President David Hoggard said that
the school's initial letter to the UDC had resulted from a parent's
complaint.
"This parent was investigating something they had
heard about a post-Civil War linkage between the UDC and the Ku Klux
Klan on the Internet," he said.
Hoggard said he found the same information on the
Internet by typing the words "UDC" and "Ku Klux Klan" into a search
engine. That led him to an article a Public Broadcasting Service
Web site that linked the carving of the UDC-sponsored Confederate
monument at Stone Mountain, Ga., with the founding of the modern KKK at
the same location.
Harrelson's mistake was in making an "unfortunate
choice of words" regarding the UDC, Hoggard said.
Margaret Carver, president of the local UDC
chapter, described Thursday's meeting as "cordial."
"I think they truly were sorry," Carver said.
Contact Tom Steadman at 574-5583 or at
tsteadman@news-record.com
See details of all the day's news in tomorrow's News
& Record
The SLRC is non profit Tax exempt South Carolina
public law firm that specializes in cases involving Southern Heritage
violations.
If anyone has received
this who does not wish to be on our distribution list, please let us
know. Our address is SLRC, P.O. Box 1235, Black Mountain, NC 28711.
Phone: 828-669-5189 Dr. Payne and Atty. Lyons SCV members, I.N.
Giffen,758, Black Mountain, NC